Pinzker & Associates
Estates & Trusts

Charitable Remainder Trust: How It Works and Who It Is Right For

charitable remainder trust

A charitable remainder trust is a way to give to charity and receive income in return, which is why it comes up so often in conversations with owners of highly appreciated assets. The structure can turn a low-basis holding into an income stream, reduce the immediate capital gains tax on a sale, and direct what remains to causes you care about.

It also comes with tradeoffs, including permanence, cost, and rules that are easy to get wrong. A charitable remainder trust is irrevocable, and the way it is drafted determines whether it delivers what the donor expected.

This post explains how the structure works, who tends to benefit, how it compares with a donor advised fund and a private foundation, and what to weigh before moving forward.

 

How a Charitable Remainder Trust Works

A donor transfers assets, often appreciated stock, real estate, or business interests, into an irrevocable trust. The trust sells the assets, and because the trust itself is generally tax-exempt, it does not owe capital gains tax at the time of the sale. That leaves the full proceeds available to reinvest.

The trust then pays income to the donor or other named beneficiaries for a set term of up to 20 years, or for life. When the term ends, whatever remains passes to one or more charities the donor selected. The donor may also receive a charitable income tax deduction based on the present value of what the charity is expected to receive, subject to adjusted gross income limits.

 

Annuity Trusts and Unitrusts

A charitable remainder annuity trust pays a fixed dollar amount each year, set when the trust is created. A charitable remainder unitrust pays a fixed percentage of the trust value, revalued annually, so the income may rise or fall with investment performance.

Federal rules generally require a payout of at least 5 percent and no more than 50 percent, and the amount projected to pass to charity must be at least 10 percent of the initial contribution. An annuity trust offers predictability and a unitrust offers the potential for income to grow with the portfolio. The right fit depends on how much income the donor needs and how long the trust is expected to run.

 

Who a Charitable Remainder Trust Tends to Fit

The structure often makes sense for people who hold a highly appreciated asset, have charitable intent, and would value a stream of income. That can include:

  • Retirees with appreciated stock or real estate who want diversified income and a lasting gift.
  • Business owners planning a sale, since the transfer generally needs to happen before a binding sale agreement is in place.
  • Executives and investors with a concentrated stock position, a risk we cover in our post on reducing concentrated stock exposure.

A charitable remainder trust may be a poor fit for someone who needs full access to the principal or has little interest in the charitable outcome, since the gift cannot be taken back once the trust is funded.

Charitable Trust vs Foundation: Comparing the Giving Options

Charitable giving strategies fall along a spectrum of control, simplicity, and income, and charitable trust planning usually starts with deciding where on that spectrum a family wants to land.

In a donor advised fund vs charitable trust comparison, the donor advised fund is typically the simpler option. A donor contributes assets to an account at a sponsoring charity, may receive an immediate deduction, and recommends grants over time. There is no income stream back to the donor, but setup is quick and ongoing administration is light.

A private foundation offers more control and a role for family members in grantmaking, along with more administrative requirements, annual distribution rules, and excise taxes on investment income. A charitable remainder trust sits between these options by paying income to the donor before the charity receives the remainder. A charitable lead trust works in the opposite order, paying charity first and passing the remainder to family.

 

Costs, Rules, and Questions to Weigh

A charitable remainder trust involves legal drafting, a trustee, annual tax filings, and ongoing investment management. Distributions to beneficiaries are taxed under a tiered system, so the character of the income, such as ordinary income or capital gains, may carry through to the person receiving it. Charitable deduction rules have also changed in recent years, so the current-year treatment of any gift should be confirmed with a tax professional.

Questions worth working through before moving forward include:

  • How much income do you need, and for how long?
  • Which assets are you considering, and what is their cost basis?
  • How does the trust fit alongside the rest of your estate plan, including any revocable or irrevocable trusts you already hold?

That last question matters because a charitable remainder trust works best as one piece of a coordinated plan, as discussed in our post on revocable vs irrevocable trusts.

Giving and Income Can Share One Plan

For the right donor, a charitable remainder trust connects three goals that often sit in separate conversations: managing a large taxable gain, creating income, and leaving a gift that lasts. Whether it fits depends on the asset, the family, and the broader estate plan, and the decision is worth making with your advisor, attorney, and tax professional at the same table.

 

Frequently Asked Questions

Can the charity be changed after the trust is set up?

Some trusts allow the donor to keep the right to change the charitable beneficiary, depending on how the document is drafted. This is a point to settle with your attorney at the outset.

Does a charitable remainder trust avoid capital gains tax?

It generally defers the tax. The trust does not pay tax when it sells the contributed asset, but beneficiaries may owe tax on a portion of the distributions they receive over time, depending on the character of the income.

Is a charitable remainder trust irrevocable?

Yes. Once the trust is funded, the donor generally cannot take the assets back, which is why the decision merits careful review before any transfer.

Book a planning conversation with Pinzker & Associates to see whether a charitable trust fits your giving and estate goals.

 

This content is provided for educational purposes only and is not tax, legal, or investment advice. Please consult your tax and legal professionals regarding your individual situation.

Securities and Investment Advisory Services offered through A.G.P. / Alliance Global Partners, Member of FINRA | SIPC.

A.G.P. / Alliance Global Partners and Pinzker & Associates are unaffiliated separate companies.

Share on LinkedIn
Check the background of this financial professional on FINRA's BrokerCheck